by keshav Singh
The debate between front-loading and top-loading machines will continue as to which of the two is the better option. You have different kinds of people, and each person has their preferences.
This article compares
the features of front-loading and top-loading washing machines from the user’s
viewpoint to help you decide on the right option.
What does the user
look for in a washing machine?
If you look at
the washing machine specifications, you can find confusing terms like
Eco wash, Eco Bubble wash, Aqua Energies, etc. These terms do not matter much
to the average user because manufacturers use such terms for marketing
purposes.
Individual washing preferences take precedence
over all matters when it comes to selecting washing machines.
As a user, you will be
more concerned with power and water efficiency, time taken for washing, the convenience
of use, washing efficiency, ease of loading, costs, and maintenance. Therefore,
we shall concentrate on these aspects to help you decide the better option
between a front load and a top load washing machine.
Table of Contents
Front Load vs Top Load
Washing machines
Ease of Use
Compared to the
front-loading washing machines, the top-loaders are generally at a comfortable
height. You do not have to bend down and go on your haunches
to load clothes into the machine. Hence, people with back problems prefer the
top-loaders.
However, top-loading
machines also require you to bend your bank when removing the clothes from the
machine. Today, you have front-loading washing machines placed over a
laundry pedestal that increases its overall height, lets you place,
and remove clothes without bending your back. The pedestal also serves as an
ideal location to store your detergents and other necessary items.
Secondly, there is a
question of adding or removing clothes during a washing cycle. Top-loading
washing machines can be stopped anytime to enable you to add or remove clothes.
The door does not have any lock. Hence, it is easy to open and convenient to
add/remove clothes whenever you want.
Some of the
front-loading machines also offer this option but early in the wash cycle. As
the cycle progresses, it is not possible to remove or add clothes.
Adding detergents is
also easy during the mid-cycle is easier in top-loading washing machines.
Inference – When it comes to ease of use, the
top-loading machines have a slight edge over their front-loading counterparts.
Cleaning Efficiency
The front-loading
washing machines are better at cleaning compared to the top-loading machines
because they offer more programs. The top front-loading washing machines such
as LG, Samsung, Bosch, IFB, and Panasonic offer 14 to 30 wash programs.
However, the average
individual does not use more than six to eight programs. Most of the other wash
programs are fancy names.
The front-loading
machines are convenient because you can wash heavy clothes like
bed sheets, cushions, etc., comfortably than a top-loading model.
The top-load washing
machines either come equipped with an agitator or an impeller. The machines
with agitator facility wash better because of the unique agitating action that
mimics a hand wash. However, clothes can get entangled in an agitator.
It can be challenging to remove clothes because of the fear of damaging them.
The machines with
impeller come with a cone or disc placed at the bottom of the drum that
spins/rotates to rub your clothes against each other to remove the dirt. It
ensures more space and also prevents clothes from entangling.
While the agitators
might not be as gentle on the clothes as the impeller, they deliver a better
cleaning performance.
Inference – The top-loading machines can be a
bit rough on clothes. Hence, the front-loader is a better option when it comes
to delivering cleaning efficiency.
Water Efficiency
Top-loading washing
machines by design work on the principles of gravity. Hence, they consume more
water to soak your clothes. This is because the clothes have to be fully
immersed in water to ensure a better wash.
On the other hand,
the front-loading machines consume less water because of their
unique design and drum rotation.
Studies have shown
that the front-loading machines consume up to 40% less water than the
top-loaders.
The BEE Star Rating
parameters comparing the front-loading and top-loading washing machines in
water efficiency are as follows.
|
Parameter |
Minimum requirement – Front Loaders |
Minimum requirement – Top Loaders |
|
Wash Performance |
>= 95% |
>= 80% |
|
Water Extraction performance |
<= 75% |
<= 75% |
|
Water Consumption |
<= 9 L/kg/cycle |
<= 23 L/kg/cycle |
|
Rinse Performance |
<= 2.25 |
<= 2.25 |
Inference – The front-loading washing machines
are better than the top-loaders in water efficiency.
Washing Speed
Compared to the
front-loading washing machines, the top-loaders have a shorter time cycle.
Features like agitators help remove stubborn dirt quickly than the machines
with impellers. While the front-loaders have more wash programs, the top-loading
machines do a better job when it comes to washing speed.
Coming to the spin
cycle, the front-loading machines have a better spin cycle, and
they remove more water than the top-loading machines. The front-loaders have a
faster spin cycle than their top-loading counterparts.
Generally, the
top-loaders have spin speeds between 650 to 800rpm, whereas the front-loading
machines spin considerably faster at 1200 to 1400rpm.
Inference – While the top-loading machines can
wash faster, the front-loaders spin faster with a higher rpm speed.
Power Efficiency
The front-loading
washing machines consume more power than a top-loader washing machine. On
average, an 8Kg front-loading washing machine consumes between 2000W to 2300W per
wash cycle. On the other hand, the top-loaders consume around 300W to 500W,
depending on the machine’s capacity.
For example, the LG
6.5Kg top-loading washing machines with inverter technology consume around 340W
to 360W.
Thus, a front-loading
washing machine can consume around 2.3 units per day if you use the machine for
one hour. On the other hand, the top-loading machines consume between 0.3 and
0.5 units per day. However, the power consumption depends on the
machine’s capacity. For example, an 8 Kg washing machine uses more power
than a 6.5 Kg appliance.
The BEE Star Rating
Plan for top-loading and front-loading washing machines are as follows.
|
Star Rating |
Energy Consumption – Front Loader – Cotton clothes @ 60
degrees Celsius |
Energy Consumption – Top-Loader – Cotton clothes @ 30
degrees Celsius |
|
Energy Consumption E per cycle in kWh/kg/cycle |
Energy Consumption E per cycle in kWh/kg/cycle |
|
|
1-Star |
0.16 < E <= 0.18 |
0.0171 < E <= 0.0185 |
|
2-Star |
0.14 < E <= 0.16 |
0.0158 < E <= 0.0171 |
|
3-Star |
0.11 < E <= 0.14 |
0.0145 < E <= 0.0158 |
|
4-Star |
0.09 < E <= 0.11 |
0.0132 < E <= 0.0145 |
|
5-Star |
E <= 0.09 |
E <= 0.0132 |
Inference – When it comes to power savings,
the top-loading washing machines save more power than the front-loading
machines.
Technology
Technology-wise, the
front-loaders offer more options because they offer more wash programs than the
top-loading machines. Besides, you have the advantage of inverter technology in
both the top-loading and front-loading machine.
LG offers Direct Drive technology with
6-motion, whereas Samsung offers its version, digital inverter technology.
Bosch machines come with Eco Silence Drive technology.
Besides, the
front-loading washing machines usually come with in-built heaters to ensure
water temperatures up to 60 degrees Celsius. Other features like foam detection
technology, Fuzzy logic, Active water technology, Aqua Energie feature,
anti-wrinkle program, etc., are also available in almost all front-loading
washing machines. Some of the high-end top-loaders also come equipped with such
technologies.
Nowadays, you have
washing machines capable of being controlled by Wi-Fi and voice assistants. In
addition, you have features like Smart Diagnosis that help
diagnose and rectify errors in the washing machine. Samsung offers Smart Things
app, whereas LG has its ThinQ smartphone apps. Panasonic has its MirAIe Wi-Fi
technology. These are similar technologies that help control and operate
washing machines using smartphone apps.
Inference – Though top-loading and
front-loading washing machines are available with the latest technologies, the
front-loaders have a slight edge in this aspect.
Noise Levels
Noise levels are
generally the same for top-loading and front-loading washing machines. The
average noise level for the washing cycle is around 50db to 60db for both these
modes.
The spinning cycle has
a higher noise level in the range of 70db to 75db. However, brands like Samsung
and Bosch make less noise compared to the LG and Whirlpool machines.
The Direct-Drive
technology available in the top-end washing machines today reduces
noise pollution because of the absence of pulleys, belts, and gears.
The drum is directly connected to the motor. Hence, there is less noise and
vibration. In addition, it allows the motor to last for extended periods.
Bosch front-loaders
are good at keeping noise levels and vibrations at a minimum because of their
sturdier side panels.
Inference – Both top-loading and front-loading
machines deliver good performance when it comes to noise levels. The range of
50db to 75db should be the average for washing and spinning cycles.
Maintenance
The front-loading
machines require more maintenance because of the formation of molds on the door
gaskets. The machine’s doors are in contact with water and detergent all the
time. Hence, there is more moisture retention in these
machines than in the top-loading models. In addition, the formation of molds
can leave an unpleasant smell. Therefore, these machines require frequent
cleaning.
Today’s washing
machine come with excellent features like Drum Clean, where the
machine runs for a couple of minutes more after you complete the running
cycles. This automatic cycle uses water and detergent to clean the
washtub of all residue to make it clean and hygienic. Almost all the
top-end models come with this feature.
Besides, you have
machines that come with hard water softening features to
reduce scaling. For example, IFB has the Aqua Energie feature that involves the
use of an in-built water softener. However, water softeners are available
easily in the market. You can use these attachments to almost all the
top-loading and front-loading machines to soften the water by removing
excessive salt. In addition, it prevents the scaling of the drum and
other parts to extend the lifespan of the machine considerably.
Some washing machine
models come with a rat mesh arrangement that prevents rodents from entering the
machine from the bottom and gnawing away at its wiring and other components.
Inference – When it comes to maintenance, the
top-loading machines are better because they incur fewer maintenance costs.
Pricing
The front-loading
washing machines are more expensive than their top-loading counterparts because
of better technology and more features. However, the top-loaders are also
available with superior technology that makes them equal to the front-loading
machines.
The pricing depends on
various factors like machine capacity, water and power efficiency, the features
available, and the technology used in its manufacture and operations. The 5-star
rated machines are more expensive than their counterparts with lower
star ratings.
At times, you find
unrated machines more expensive than 5-star rated models because these machines
are imported directly from places like Vietnam and China.
Inference – Generally, front-loading machines
are more expensive than the top-loaders.
Installation
The front loading
washing machine occupy less space than the top-loaders. Besides, they
offer free storage space above the machine to enable you to stack dryers, etc.
The top-loading machines do not offer such liberties.
You can also install
the front-loading machines on a pedestal to increase their height. In addition,
the pedestal can serve as a storage space for detergents and other
washing machine maintenance items.
Inference – Installation-wise, the
front-loading washing machines are a better option.
Tabular Comparison
Here is a tabular
comparison of the front-loader and top-loader washing machines to enable you to
compare these appliances at a glance.
|
Comparison Parameters |
Front-loading machines |
Top-loading machines |
|
Ease of Use |
Not recommended for people with back issues because of the
low height |
More accessible to load clothes than the front-loading
machines |
|
Cleaning Efficiency |
Much better than the top-loading machines, especially when
washing delicate clothes |
The top-loaders with agitators deliver good performance
but can be a bit rough on clothes. |
|
Water Consumption |
Consume up to 40% less water than top-loaders |
Consumes more water |
|
Washing Speed |
Lower washing speed but have more washing cycles and
higher spin speeds |
Better than front-loaders because of faster washing cycles |
|
Power Consumption |
Consumes more power than top-loading washing machines |
In comparison, the top-loaders consume less power than
front-loaders. |
|
Technology |
Come with more technological features |
Has fewer technological features |
|
Noise Levels |
Slightly more than the top-loading counterparts |
Slightly better than the front-loaders, but more or less
equal |
|
Maintenance |
Requires more maintenance because of mold formation |
Requires less maintenance |
|
Pricing |
Expensive compared to top-loading machines |
Less expensive than front-loaders |
|
Installation |
Occupies less space and is more flexible |
Does not offer much flexibility |
Comparison – Top Load
vs Front Load Models
|
Parameters |
Whirlpool – Stainwash Ultra 7.0 |
Samsung – WA70T4262GS/TL |
Samsung – WW70T502DAX/TL |
IFB – Serena WX |
|
Type |
Top-loading |
Top-loading |
Front-loading |
Front-loading |
|
Capacity |
7 Kg – ideal for families with 3
to 4 persons |
7Kg – suited for families with 3
to 4 people |
7Kg – ideal for small families |
7Kg – ideal for small families, 3
to 4 persons |
|
Warranty |
Two years on the product plus ten
years on the motor |
Three years warranty plus
twelve years on the motor |
Three years on the product plus
ten years on the motor |
Four years on the product and four
years on the motor |
|
Wash programs |
Eight |
Six |
Twenty-two |
Fifteen |
|
Special Features |
Inverter motor |
Inverter motor with digital
inverter technology |
Inverter technology |
Aqua Energie |
|
Power Consumption |
360W |
340W to 380W |
Around 2000W to 2200W |
Around 2000W |
|
Star Rating |
5-star |
5-star |
Unrated, imported from Vietnam |
5-star |
|
| ||||
|
Noise Levels |
Average 62db |
50db to 59db |
56db to 70db |
56db to 70db |
|
Water Consumption |
Average of 140L |
Average of 140L |
65L to 72L per wash cycle |
65L to 72L per wash cycle |
Comments
Post a Comment